Should children under 7 be held criminally responsible for crimes

Messenger The age of criminal responsibility acts as the gateway to the criminal justice system — under a certain age you are kept out. But what age is the right age? And how do legal systems deal with this difficult question? What is the age of criminal responsibility?

Should children under 7 be held criminally responsible for crimes

This section does not cite any sources. Please help improve this section by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. December Learn how and when to remove this template message This is an aspect of the public policy of parens patriae.

In the criminal laweach state will consider the nature of its own society and the available evidence of the age at which antisocial behaviors begins to manifest itself. Some societies will have qualities of indulgence toward the young and inexperienced, and will not wish them to be exposed to the criminal law system before all other avenues of response have been exhausted.

Hence, some states have a policy of doli incapax i.


However, although no criminal liability is inferred, other aspects of law may be applied. For example, in Nordic countries, an offense by a person under 15 years of age is considered mostly a symptom of problems in child's development.

This will cause the social authorities to take appropriate administrative measures to secure the development of the child. Such measures may range from counseling to placement at special care unit.

Being non-judicial, the measures are not dependent on the severity of the offense committed but on the overall circumstances of the child. The policy of treating minors as incapable of committing crimes does not necessarily reflect modern sensibilities.

Thus, if the rationale of the excuse is that children below a certain age lack the capacity to form the mens rea of an offense, this may no longer be a sustainable argument. Indeed, given the different speeds at which people may develop both physically and intellectually, any form of explicit age limit may be arbitrary and irrational.

Yet, the sense that children do not deserve to be exposed to criminal punishment in the same way as adults remains strong. Children have not had experience of life, nor do they have the same mental and intellectual capacities as adults.

Hence, it might be considered unfair to treat young children in the same way as adults.

Should children under 7 be held criminally responsible for crimes

In Scotland the age of criminal responsibility is currently eight years, however age of criminal prosecution was raised to 12 in SwedenFinlandand Norway all set the age at fifteen years. In the United Statesthe age varies between statesbeing as low as six years in South Carolina and seven years in 35 states; 11 years is the minimum age for federal crimes.

As the treaty parties of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court could not agree on a minimum age for criminal responsibility, they chose to solve the question procedurally and excluded the jurisdiction of the Court for persons under eighteen years.

Some countries refuse to set a fixed minimum age, but leave discretion to prosecutors to argue or the judges to rule on whether the child or adolescent "juvenile" defendant understood that what was being done was wrong. If the defendant did not understand the difference between right and wrong, it may not be considered appropriate to treat such a person as culpable.

Alternatively, the lack of real fault in the offender can be recognized by rulings that dispense mitigated criminal sentences or address more practical matters of parental responsibility by adjusting the rights of parents to unsupervised custody, or by separate criminal proceedings against the parents for breach of their duties as parents.

Ages of criminal responsibility by country[ edit ] The following are the minimum ages at which people may be charged with a criminal offence in each country:Apr 07,  · Best Answer: Generally by everyone should be considered fully liable for their actions.

Not everyone is, but that's a good cutoff for 'fully liable'.

Should children under 7 be held criminally responsible for crimes

Younger - down to about 10 or 12 - for especially bad crimes that show intent and knowledge of Status: Resolved. Children in the higher age group, between 10 and 14 years old, can be convicted of criminal offences only if the prosecution can refute the presumption of doli incapax. This can be done by proving.

At What Age Can We Hold Juveniles Criminally Responsible? becomes old enough to be held criminally children charged with crimes are not. All states and the federal government have come to these same conclusions: Older juveniles can be held criminally responsible in some cases.

Some people are hopelessly, defectively dangerous even at . Sep 13,  · In the US, no. Children 6 yrs old can not be held responsible for their actions. They may be remanded, by the juvenile court to a psychiatric hospital, if they are found to be a threat to themselves or others, up to the age of 18 to 21 yrs old, depending on state Resolved.

Should Children Under 7 Be Held Criminally Responsible For Crimes. Responsible for the Crimes of their Children How can someone who does not commit a crime get charged for the crime committed.

at what age should people be held criminally liable for their actions? | Yahoo Answers